A 1974 movie called the great mcgonagall starred spike milligan as a fictionalised william mcgonagall. After the success of the surreal, semistream of conscious puckoon, it took over a decade for milligan to produce with jack hobbs william mcgonagall. This was the story where our hero had to confront the villains of his past. Im not hungry i groaned and pushed hermiones fork away and the boys looked at me. Seeing our hogwarts favourites all band together in such a riveting way really set the tone for the chapter to come. But that doesnt really answer my question about who would win an actual duel. A professor at hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry, snape is hostile to harry due to his resemblance to his father james, who bullied snape during their time at hogwarts. Headmaster severus snape vs professor mcgonagall in hd. In 2016, a fan film prequel, severus snape and the marauders, was released online and snape was played by mick ignis. Harry potter and the cursed child broadway shows announce third year main cast. The sacking of severus snape wikibooks, open books for. It is said that one day he took a nap in a chair in the staff room and died in his sleep.
All the duels were good, but seeing mcgonagall vs snape in action was pretty cool. The harry potter books from severus snapes perspective. This doodle page lets the kids create their own spellbook cover from scratch, with room to draw and write on the front and back. Mcgonagall is shown to have a strong offense in fact it nearly overwhelmed snape in the book.
Character subjectposition background cuthbert binns history of magic. Amy woke up 1 week later and her friends told her what happened and the visitors she has had in that time. Mcgonagall brandished her wand at a torch on the wall and it flew out of its bracket. Albus dumbledore, severus snape, and minerva mcgonagall are some of the most powerful and wellrespected professors hogwarts has ever seen. Lets put aside the whole plan to kill voldemort, which was obviously a factor as to why snape wouldnt fight back. Having defeated alecto and amycus carrow on the ravenclaw tower, harry potter and luna lovegood both under the invisibility cloak along with minerva mcgonagall went down. The sacking of severus snape wikibooks, open books for an. The history of magic teacher for the entire series, cuthbert binns has the distinction of being the only teacher at hogwarts who is a ghost. This skill likewise may be helping him deflect the magic mcgonagall is throwing at him, though it is equally possible that mcgonagall, knowing his ability, is using occlumency, as much as she is able to, to block snapes probes.
She is the transfiguration instructor at hogwarts and head of the gryffindor house. Kmc forums movies movie discussion movie versus forum mcgonagall, snape, and bellatrix vs voldemort. As you know, for the majority of the books professor mcgonagall gracefully played second fiddle to albus dumbledores headmaster. Sirius black, remus lupin, peter pettigrew and james potter the bullies of snapes youth, with one of them happening to be the man who married the love of his life, lily. Apr 29, 2014 headmaster severus snape vs professor mcgonagall in hd. Snape can cloak his mind from other people trying to read it, and there is no evidence mcgonagall possesses this power. In episode of season 2 of the canadian tv series murdoch mysteries, a murder victim is holding a copy of a book entitled the collected works of william topaz mcgonagall. Harry potter and the deathly hallows that was not in the book. Mcgonagall welcomes students to hogwarts both literally and figuratively she writes the admission letters and also greets them when they enter to be sorted. The daughter of albus dumbledore and minerva mcgonagall book 1.
They both become headmaster and headmistress someday, and mcgonagall is older than snape seeing as when snape was in school mcgonagall was still deputy headmistress, but snape too, is very skilled and learned from lord voldemort. I feel like the movie snape was a lot more likable than the book snape by far. He spent the next twentyfive years appalling and delighting audiences with his disjointed, creaky and sometimes just plain bad verse. And this is not the book, but the movie where we these things have been highlighted. Click here to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links. The truth at last, and the development or perhaps degradation of spikes narrative style is on full display in this book. After his death at the hands of her own colleague snape for reasons she didnt realise at the time, we cant even fathom how horrendous hogwarts must have been during harrys wouldhavebeen final year. They asked and they dropped their forks and harry felt my forehead. See more ideas about harry potter, hogwarts and maggie smith.
William topaz mcgonagall was a selfeducated hand loom weaver who, in dundee in 1877, felt the poetic muse upon him. She knew, even back then, all those years ago, that she could love him with all her heart. Imagine if you had your own book of spells what would you call it. Minerva mcgonagallseverus snape works archive of our own. Severus snape was potions master, defense against the dark arts teacher, and head of slytherin at hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry. Minerva attended hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry and was sorted into gryffindor house, but it took the sorting hat five and a half minutes to decide if she was gryffindor or.
The chapter that made us fall in love with professor. Seeing here going thru so much emotions is amazing. Mcgonagall, sprout and flitwick duel snape in the great hall after harry returns and informs them that snape killed dumbledore. Minerva mcgonagall in harry potter and the sorcerers. In the movie harry kept the secret of hunting horcruxes to himself, ron and hermione as per dumbledores explicit instructions. Part 2 instead of mcgonagall, who fought snape in the book. Snape likely perceived harrys presence under the invisibility cloak. Filch lurks in the doorway, eying them with pleasure. Could she lie to the dark lord and get away with it. The unwelcome reunion occured when potters old friend remus lupin secured snapes dream job of. Before long, a frankly awesome duel ensued between mcgonagall, flitwick, sprout and snape, the three fellow professors chipping in to end snapes reign once and for all. She has always been a strong woman and her loyalty has never waivered. Mcgonagall then sent a orange streak of light at snape, as snape sent a blue streak.
Differences between harry potter and the deathly hallows. Take this away, put mcgonagall and snape 1 on 1 and who would win. She doesnt understand why snape, mcgonagall or the headteacher was there. The chapter that made us fall in love with professor mcgonagall. However, they have radically different personalities and approaches to life. The series focuses much more on severus snapes magical prowess and his mastery of occlumency which is amazing, but very little information is av. He is an exceptionally skilful wizard whose coldly sarcastic and controlled exterior conceals deep emotions and anguish. Theres no question that professor mcgonagall has a profound loyalty to her students and to the institution of hogwarts, and this is made abundantly clear when she engages in a duel with snape in an attempt to chase him out of the school. Harry, about to curse snape, was forced to pull luna out of the way of the descending flames, which became a ring of fire that filled the corridor and flew like a lasso at snape then it was no longer fire, but a great, black serpent that mcgonagall blasted. Rowling fought for mcgonagalls battle the mary sue. It doesnt take anyone a full minute to close a book, put that book in a back pack and walk out a door. Mcgonagall vs snape, a harry potter fanfic fanfiction. Who would win a duel between severus snape and minerva.
This scene shows just how much of a badass duelist she is, even if, at the same time, we cant help but feel a bit sad about just how far hogwarts has fallen. He was personally killed by lord voldemort and his snake, nagini. First class, was a scottish halfblood witch, the only daughter of muggle robert mcgonagall and witch isobel ross. Professor minerva mcgonagalls 10 best moments in harry. Note that the poetic gems book in which a particular poem was published has no bearing on when it was written. This skill likewise may be helping him deflect the magic mcgonagall is throwing at him, though it is equally possible that mcgonagall, knowing his ability, is using occlumency, as much as she is able to, to block snape s probes. Professor mcgonagall colouring page 2 activity village. Umbridge vs mcgonagall, a harry potter fanfic fanfiction.
The ousting of severus snape also improperly referred to as the sacking of severus snape was a duel between severus snape, then headmaster of hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry, and the hogwarts heads of houses. In the modern era, the entire series is reprinted in a single collection called the complete mcgonagall. Rowling, on fighting the decision to pit harry potter against severus snape in harry potter and the deathly hallows. Mcgonagall woukd win hands down and you know she would if you have ever had the courtesy to read the book. Hands down, snape is more powerful than mcgonagall. I havent read the last book but we hear neville talk about them in the movie. For younger children, a colouring page featuring the popular professor mcgonagall. Whats the difference between harry potter and the deathly hallows the book and harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 the movie. Though other professors come and go the two heads of house routinely meet by the staff room fireside on friday nights to cope with the struggles of teaching at a magical school filled with teenagers. As is confirmed in the tales of beedle the bard, mcgonagall becomes headmistress of hogwarts after the battle of hogwarts and snape s death. The daughter of albus dumbledore and minerva mcgonagall. Others obviously did too, as can be seen from the contemporary testimonials reproduced in the short autobiography which begins the book, from, amongst others, admiring followers from glasgow university no less.
Its been 20 years since we all met the boy who lived. She also was the older sister of malcolm and robert jr. If they met in combat with no outside influence, who would come out on top. He was fighting for dear life and when sprout, slughorn and flitwick came, he had to flee. He is a talented occumulens, which means he is the only person capable of lying to voldemort. When she drives snape away from hogwarts theres no question that professor mcgonagall has a profound loyalty to her students and to the institution of hogwarts, and this is made abundantly clear when she engages in a duel with snape in an attempt to chase him out of the school. Camera pulls back, professor severus snape stands at his desk, newspaper in hand as me, harry and ron stare with dread. Mcgonagall, snape, and bellatrix vs voldemort textonly version. Severus snape and minerva mcgonagall have a long standing tradition that cannot be stopped. Below the fold a photo shows harry, amy and lockhart at flourish and blotts. Boasting magical knowledge and abilities second only to dumbledore.
It would be a close duel, but mcgonagall would emerge victorious. Having defeated alecto and amycus carrow on the ravenclaw tower. In september 1998, harry potter and the sorcerers stone was released in the u. I replied shortly, not looking up at her toadlike face. What does the duel between snape and mcgonagall reveal. In the book, minerva mcgonagall is the one who does it and for me it was very important that she did that. The book snape was a complete jerk with no care for whats right and wrong. The most startling incident in my life, writes mcgonagall, was the time i discovered myself to be a poet, which was in the year 1877. Mcgonagalls poems were published by his friends, in a series of books bearing variations on the title poetic gems. About snape, i did wonder what he must have been thinking when he was being overthrown. Say what you want about albus dumbledore and harry potter being the best characters to walk the halls of hogwarts.
In there you will find mcgonagall out matching snape true he fled to the other heads of. He bullies students to the verge of tears, is blatantly biased towards slytherins, and does not care for an innocent life just because of a childhood grudge. Apr 04, 2010 whos better at duel between these two harry potter characters. In there you will find mcgonagall out matching snape true he fled to the other heads of houses arrival but jk rowling herself has said on a fan answer page. Wizards unite game announces book night, valentines day events in feb. When so many people including snape before biting the dust point out the fact that harry has his mothers eyes, despite the fact that the actors in the movies had eyes that couldnt be more different if they tried, the translation from book to screen is marred from the getgo. Having defeated alecto and amycus carrow on the ravenclaw tower, harry potter and luna lovegood both under the invisibility cloak along with minerva mcgonagall went.
1544 1302 1512 332 1057 1302 1242 465 1100 155 1408 578 1266 708 914 696 999 1399 428 1379 232 1085 381 1362 1077 1263 1314 1350